ABOUT THIS ENTRY
This page contains a single entry by Mark Willen
published on
December 1, 2008 12:12 AM.
Governing from Outside the Beltway was the previous entry.
Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.
IMMIGRATION
Immigration High on Obama's Priority List
It's not getting much attention -- not with more pressing economic and national security issues -- but President-elect Obama is quietly laying the groundwork for a big push later this year on a comprehensive immigration bill.
He's already designated two point persons -- his former opponent, Arizona Sen. John McCain, and his new secretary of Homeland Security, soon-to-be-ex-Arizona Gov. Janet Napolitano. It's a match made in heaven.
When Obama met with McCain last month, it wasn't just a courtesy call. The president-elect was reaching out and looking for issues on which the two former adversaries could work together. Immigration was high on the list. It didn't figure much in the campaign for the very reason it's ripe for cooperation; there's little daylight between the McCain and Obama positions. The two men agreed to work together on the measure, and Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., who was there, agreed to help.
By picking Janet Napolitano as his head of Homeland Security, which includes Customs and Immigration Enforcement, Obama was also picking someone ideally suited to help craft an immigration policy. As governor of a border state, she took a practical stand that won her allies in competing camps. She was the first to seek help in guarding the border from National Guard troops, but she has questioned the wisdom of building a border fence on the grounds that it's too costly and won't work well enough. When the Arizona legislature passed a bill imposing the toughest-in-the-nation sanctions on employers who hire illegal aliens, she came to the defense of the business community, which opposed the bill, and signed it only after fighting for some modifications. She knows the immigration problem as well as anyone in Washington -- probably better than anyone in Washington.
Why would Obama look for a fight on this issue when he has so many seemingly bigger fish to fry? First, it's a major problem that begs for a better answer than stirring up prejudice and denying businesses the workers they'll need when the economy recovers. Second, Obama owes something to Hispanics, many of whom are disappointed that one of their own, New Mexico Gov. Bill Richardson, didn't get the secretary of State nod (he'll settle for Commerce.). Third, it's a way to do something that business wants (and unions don't), allowing Obama to show he's not all pro-labor and anti-business.
Obama, McCain and Napolitano will push for a bill that looks a lot like the one President Bush championed unsuccessfully -- including a large guest worker plan and some path to legal status for the millions of illegal immigrants already in the U.S.
Passage won't come easy. While some of the loudest, most vociferous congressional voices are no longer in Washington (i.e., Colorado Republican Rep. Tom Tancredo), proponents must still contend with a vocal minority, egged on by popular broadcast personalities, namely Rush Limbaugh and Lou Dobbs. But with a bigger Democratic majority in the House and a strong bipartisan push in the Senate, it just might happen in Obama's first year in office.
0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Immigration High on Obama's Priority List.
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blog.kiplinger.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/365
6 Comments
Leave a comment
RECENT BLOG ENTRIES
MORE POLITICAL COVERAGE FROM KIPLINGER
OUR FAVORITE SITES
- Real Clear Politics
- Politico (Political news)
- Political Wire
- The Huffington Post
- The Weekly Standard
- Memeorandum (General news)
- The Page (Time)
- The Note (ABC News)
- Open Secrets (Campaign finance)
- Under the Influence (Lobbying)
- The Concord Coalition (Government spending)
- Taxes (Brookings)
- The Poynter Institute (Media)


DIGG
This blog is a very helpful guide to potential strategy re: immigration reform. Let's see if the hard-core Left, somewhat anxious about Obama's pragmatism, will be willing to give him necessary support in this area where reform is so necessary. I hope so. I continue to be very heartened by Obama and the decisions he is making.
You're kidding yourself if you think the opposition will be any weaker. Most Americans oppose amnesty for law breakers and there's enough of us to kill it. Obama would be wise not to try.
The McCain-Kennedy bill is the best way to go. We cannot deport 11 million undocumented aliens. Let's deport the criminals, but give a deserving chance to the hard-working immigrants.
Obama would be smart to push for immigration reform not only for the reasons stated in this article, but also because doing so would create thousands of government and public sector jobs.
Immigration reform that includes a pathway to legal status for the estimated 15million people unlawfully present also would come at no cost to the taxpayer because USCIS is the only self-funding agency; its funds come from filing fees paid by the individuals seeking immigration benefits.
Assume that 80% of 15million are admissible to the country except for the fact they overstayed a visa or entered illegally. Assess them a $5,000 penalty and that generates $60billion. It will not cost $60billion to process those applications, so the money leftover can be used to improve immigration law enforcement (to prevent a recurrence of our current situation) and to provide funding to states to cope with the healthcare and education needs of immigrants.
How about employing already-unemployed Americans who already have the right to be in this country and have properly paid their taxes/dues? I think they should get priority.
I'm an employed minority who immigrated into the States via my parents through proper legal documentation processes.
I still think that we need to focus on saving the people who already have the right to be here than saving the ones who broke the laws getting in, costing us more tax dollars, and take the jobs we need. Yeah, maybe they kept our costs low because of cheap labor, but what does that matter now when Americans are on high-unemployment these days? Heck, I would take anything today, too, just to make ends meet. It's frustrating to see that American adults/teenagers can't even get a job at fast food restaurants because it goes to illegals who conned their way into a SSN#.
And who knows what diseases are getting re-introduced into this country because they bypass the proper medical checks upon entry. I understand that illegal immigrants can be hard workers, but wait until you or your loved one gets stricken with a disease or needs that job at McDonalds to avoid losing a roof over their head.
Moza said "We cannot deport 11 million undocumented aliens. Let's deport the criminals"
I thought an illegal alien was a criminal....